you're reading...

The Press Coverage of Shannon Matthews and The Madeleine McCann Case

A fortnight or so into the investigation surrounding the disappearance of Madeleine McCann Simon Schama postulated thus on Question Time;


If Madeleine had been the daughter of a black single parent from South London, and the occurrence had taken place at Butlins, would there be the same level of media interest?”


There was a sharp collective intake of breath (we were still at the Diana Stage), a pause and then a ripple of acknowledgement washed across the audience.


Shannon Matthews disappeared from her home in Dewsbury a week ago today.


Not ONE mention on Sky News who at this stage in the McCann case were anchoring their main bulletins from Portugal, nor on the Today Programme or News 24. A trawl of Ceefax produced the same result. Nothing. Diddlysquat.


This from the Mirror;


A man helping in the search for Shannon Matthews was found nailed to a cross.


A neighbour who found him said; “He was shouting “Jesus Christ over and over. He was drunk so I told him to get up, but he said; “I can’t””.


Police deny any connection to her disappearance.


Shannon’s Mum Karen (32) said she and her boyfriend Craig Meehan (22) could not bear to go home.


A pal said; “They are beside themselves”.


This coverage would be funny if it did not epitomise the contempt that the Red Top Press has for it’s largely Working Class readership.


The scenario described is to suggest that life in Working Class areas is one big episode of Shameless, as you can well imagine Frank Gallagher in such a situation.


Feckless, drunk and immoral bludgers, the lot of ‘em.


Just the demographic that New Labour have in their sights as described by the lamentable Caroline Flint last month when she called for those who won’t work to be made homeless.


Then there is the description of Meehan as the “boyfriend”. Not partner. It makes the mother seem all the more irresponsible and immoral. “She takes boyfriends!” Then there is the mention of Meehan’s age, thrown in for added moral outrage.


On top of that the friend of the family is described as a “pal”. Throwaway, expendable, worthless.


And those three words describe the attitude of the media to the White Working Class and why Shannon’s desperate situation barely registers in Tabloid Land.


The Express/Mail faux Middle Class readership are made to feel frightened by the McCann case as “IT COUD BE YOU!” feeding their idea that they are on the same socio- educational rung as the McCanns.


They aren’t, but this contemptible niche market in the Press con their readers into thinking that stuff Inheritance Tax affects them, and make them feel like they should be concerned. And vote Tory accordingly, whilst casting an insidious aspersion that this family, and the Mother in particular were the architects of their own misfortune by the way they live their lives.


More pertinently how we are made to assume that a chaotic lifestyle is abroad here. We have no idea of course, but the seeds are planted. 


 What the Matthews case shows in microcosm is how fractured Society has become, and that Working Class people are increasingly portrayed by the media in the same way that Orwell painted a picture of life for the Proles in 1984.


About dermotrathbone

Writer and co author "Through Red Lenses". Activist Unite the Union, Save Our NHS Hull. Fan of Yorkshire County Cricket Club, Hull FC, Munster and Ireland Rugby. Views are mine alone and may not reflect the organisations concerned.


16 thoughts on “The Press Coverage of Shannon Matthews and The Madeleine McCann Case

  1. And why has there been no organised press conference with the police? Instead the mother has been forced to make appeals to whatever camera crews are around instead of it being done in a proper, official manner. It adds  to the whole perception that the situation they are living in is chaotic and disorganised and that they are in some way responsible for what has happened.

    Posted by rebecca | February 27, 2008, 12:30 pm
  2. With all due to the respects that have been made here, perhaps the mother doesn’t want the police to make an appeal on her behalf.
    Maybe, just maybe, the "family" are in some way responsible for these tragic events. There’s little doubt the McCanns behaved irresponcibly, nor the fact they are well educated "middle class" people means they’ve been a good news story for the Daily Mail and Express. Far be it for me to judge the "chaotic & disorganised" situation in the Mathews case, but it is probably a sad reality of modern life that a mother seperated from the child’s father & now with a "boyfriend" several years younger doesn’t give the same kind of family ethos togetherness you get from the media coverage of little Madeline.
    The fact remains, two children are missing, something any parent should find upsetting beyond belief.
    Whether the children are black, white, poor, rich, one-legged etc should be & is totally irrelevant.   

    Posted by Michael | March 3, 2008, 7:58 am
  3. Well considering they are both desparate cases. I agree with you to somw extent, what do you see as a sotution to media predudice in it’s coverage? These stories need to avoid sensationalism and merely stating facts.

    Posted by Cicero | March 3, 2008, 5:17 pm
  4. Sorry I meant add that these media houses really should stick to fact rather than repeat sensationalism and  speculation

    Posted by Cicero | March 3, 2008, 5:21 pm
  5. wow gold!All wow gold US Server 24.99$/1000G on sell! Cheap wow gold,wow gold,wow gold,Buy Cheapest/Safe/Fast WoW US EU wow gold Power leveling wow gold from the time you wWorld of Warcraft gold ordered!

    wow power leveling wow power leveling power leveling wow power leveling wow powerleveling wow power levelingcheap wow power leveling wow power leveling buy wow power leveling wow power leveling buy power leveling wow power leveling cheap power leveling wow power leveling wow power leveling wow power leveling wow powerleveling wow power leveling power leveling wow power leveling wow powerleveling wow power leveling buy rolex cheap rolex wow gold wow gold wow gold wow gold -18653693361323

    Posted by Unknown | June 3, 2008, 6:29 am
  6. qswd030 qswd00 wow gold wow power leveling wow gold wow power leveling brogame brogame buy worhammer gold buy worhammer gold 大金空调 大金空调 空调 空调 格力空调 格力空调 美的空调 美的空调 东方医院 东方医院 油泵 油泵 真空泵 真空泵 胶体磨 胶体磨 中央空调 中央空调 商用中央空调 商用中央空调 螺杆泵 螺杆泵 brogame brogame brogame brogame brogame brogame brogame wow gold wow gold

    Posted by Unknown | November 3, 2008, 3:18 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 898 other followers


%d bloggers like this: